Jonathan Robertson's Online Review Report Card

This is a long overdue review. I saw Dr. Robertson after a year of pain and PT, she reviewed MRI and determined I had a Labrum Tear. Did the surgery to reattach labrum and bicep tendosis as well. She had to drill my bone twice because first time the drill broke. She probably let some inexperienced resident in training perform surgery on me. So I ended up with 2 holes.I started PT 2 weeks later, I was having pain in the front of the shoulder whenever I would row (movements involving the bicep)4 months later I fell and the bicep tendon snapped.She admitted that should not have happened because the tendon should be healed by month 4. I saw multiple doctors and all confirmed.Before going in surgery to attach the bicep tendon I asked her about symmetry and if she can make sure the bicep is symmetrical to the other bicep. She said its no problem and that is easy and there is no problem or risk.I got out of surgery , she said everything went fine. Later I discovered that she wrote in the surgery notes she discussed with me risks and possibility of popeye deformity (bicep asymmetry). That is a straight lie. And I got out of surgery with a popeye deformity. I told her at my 2 week follow up she acted shocked and unaware of the deformity saying everything was fine during surgery. More lies. She kept saying she does not know what is going on.She offered to go in and try to fix. She said she would lift the tendon and attach higher and tension it correctly. I agreed to it. I came out she said she fixed it but did not re-tension the tendon. She lifted the fascia tissue.Again I go home and I check , and popeye is still there. I ended up with a click near the elbow where she stitched the fascia. And every time I ask her about reason for the popeye and why she did not tension the tendon she gives me a different answer that is contradicting to the previous answer.I, still till this day, do not know what went wrong and is the problem.On top of this , PT injured my rotator cuff and when I asked to see her , her office refused and wanted me to go to PT. PT created the problem and asked me to see the dr. Lots of back and forth till they scheduled me4 weeks later. I was in so much pain. I could not work for 3 weeks. I had a re-tear of the labrum , Rotator cuff tendosis all around ( weak RT tendons) and a thin bicep tendon leading to big possibility of snapping the tendon again. I waited 45 minutes , she saw me for 20 minutes , offered no solutions and no hope as well. Made me think I may never recover and never workout and just accept living like a 70 year old. And on top of that she said she said she had to leave because she had commitments after work (it was close to 5PM close time on Friday), but it's ok to make me wait 45 minutes to see her to tell me nothing and offer no solution.3 surgeries in one year and 3 years later, I still am suffering from the RT injury and Bicep issue. I can't lift weights and am scared the tendon might snap and feel lots of bicep pain when I curl. I lived through 3 years of hell and stress that led to lots of Chronic issues I am dealing with right now due to what she put me through.

This review has been removed for violating our Terms of Service

Update after being told by Dr Robertson's PA that DR. Robertson said It was most likely I would be worse if I had surgery (the Dr never even met with me although I requested it numerous times.) I am so happy to say it's been 5 wks since my surgery and I could cry with happiness. My labrum was severely detached and the bones were grinding against each other,I had a nerve and a muscle entrapment, along with a few minor issues. As a daughter of a Dr I do not say this lightly, I've never been more disgusted with a Dr. In my entire life. She should be ashamed to call herself a Dr giving advice on a patient she never met and stealing away all my hope. I cried for days thinking I would never live a normal life again. Thankfully the Dr took the time and knew I needed help and knew he had the skills to accomplish it. I'm so happy I went to him and didn't listen to DR. Robertson. I would still be in bed crying if I did. Please don't trust someone who can't even give you a moment to see the entire picture. To add insult to injury her office ironically called me to discuss and I mentioned I just had surgery a few days prior. They told me I was considered a non operative patient and that only angered me more as I did need surgery and based on her not meeting me and taking a glimpse of my MRI she made an assessment that was beyond incorrect. I was explained and know from experience MRI's don't always show the depth of the issue. Do not let her steal your hope. There are Drs out there with exceptional skills, who take the time to speak with the patient and help them.. DR Alexander Weber is located in LA and has a stellar reputation and even is the Physician for the USC Trojans. Please get another opinion as that could be the one which changes your life!! Btw I highly recommend him!!

I recently made an appointment and was told I would only see her PA. After the appointment I was left hopeless and requested to meet with the DR. I was blown off and again told most likely my hip would be worse after surgery. I wanted her to understand the entire picture as I've had numerous spine surgeries and it was making everything much worse. I've been bed ridden for months and in constant pain. I've tried shots, PT, bed rest and I'm not better. I'm going on 2 yrs and it's only getting worse. Fortunately my parents are both in the medical field and took charge in finding me other DRS who specialize in this field. Both are highly skilled and trained . After meeting with them they both were shocked she wouldn't meet with me and both disagreed that I would be worse after surgery. This is a perfect example of a bad Doctor. Taking away hope,but yet they never examined me or took the time to see the entire picture. I've spent many yrs with the Drs at UCSD and have never experienced anything like this. I don't want other patients to suffer the way I have and I don't want them to settle for a DR who can't even take the time. Go elsewhere you will be happy you did!!

I was referred to Dr. Robertson by a friend as a top Sports Medicine physician. However, my experience was very poor.I needed meniscus surgery. Dr. Robertson said I would be back to 100% health in 6-8 weeks. However, after still having knee pain at 6 weeks, she told me to start running and not come back to see her. It took me a year and a half of careful physical therapy and new related injuries along the way to get back to current state of 90-95%. However, Dr. Robertson had no interest in my condition or recovery after the surgery, despite having issues caused by the surgery. I'm in my early 30s and very physically active.

This is a long-overdue review! Dr. Robertson perform my ACL reconstruction and meniscus repair around June of 2020. It's been more than a year now and i am doing well. Due to multiple unfortunate events - from getting injured, finding an incompetent group/doc, to moving in 2 weeks. I ended up with Dr. R!!!! I entered her office with anxiety, and she made a plan for me like a group of superheroes. She answered all my questions and she even showed me the MRI images and explained to me what happened to my knee. She was able to perform surgery on my knee a week before I moved. This was my first surgery, and she made it perfect. I am really grateful for all you did for me Dr. R!!!!!! She is the best!!!!!!

Catherine convinced me to get a hip arthroscopy instead of a hip replacement. I was at that time a Registered Nurse at UCSD in the ER- I was medically separated from that job after her surgery crippled me. She neglected to inform me of common side effects of the recovery of that surgery- I developed hip flexor tendinitis, hamstring tendinitis, obturator trigger point spasm, nerve damage...and my knee was so severely damaged from the traction during the surgery I could barely bear weight on it. During the "recovery", Catherine largely ignored my complaints, offering nothing but physical therapy (her therapists admitted to me that they had never recovered a patient from this crippling tendinopathy despite having many patients develop it), she offered nsaids and cortisone. When asked what this crippling pain in the posterior hip was, for 8 months she said "I don't know what that is" despite never even doing a simple clinical assessment of the area. She rushed through appointments despite her surgery ruining my life. I couldn't even walk around the block, my pain level was through the roof 24/7, I couldn't work, I lost everything. I drained 401k accounts, I lost a year doing anything with my kids, I could not even sit in a chair (I still can't a year later). I've spent $20k on stem cells which is the only reason I can walk, I can't run, I can't surf, I can't make a living for my family. She didn't care at all, she just wanted me out of her office because she's one of the "trailblazers" in this disastrous surgery and only likes good outcomes. I've since spoken to countless physical therapists that have described how they have seen countless disastrous outcomes of this surgery. It's unethical that none of these complications are even discussed. When I tried to make the hip surgery a work comp claim retroactively to save my job, my lawyer pulled Catherine's my charts. When I asked her why my claim was getting so much pushback, my lawyer told me that Catherine never chatted any of my complaints. In fact, from her charting, it didn't sound like the recovery went that badly, and there was no mention of any of the complaints of pain I would later find out was due to the nerve damage. to put it simply: CATHERINE KNOWINGLY LIED ON HER CHARTING TO MAKE IT SEEM LIKE HER SURGERY WAS A SUCCESS. Catherine Robertson has absolutely no empathy, no accountability, and no morals in her approach to medicine. She ruined my life, don't let her ruin yours.

Hands down the best surgeon of all time. I was having issues with my insurance and seen by many doctors till I ended up with Dr. Robertson. Blessing in disguise? Yea, I think so! She was kind, compassionate and held my hand through the entire process. I had a complete ruptured ACL, bucket tear lateral meniscus, and a fractured tibial plateau. I'm only 28 and she kept that in mind and told me I would be ok and she would see to it. She kept her word! It's been about 6 months and I am still healing of course but healing beautifully. I've seen scars other people with the exact same injuries as myself and man they look pretty bad. I look at mine and feel blessed. She did an amazing job you can barely even see my scars. The staff is great, starting from the front desk and how can I forget her right hand Dr. Jackie, she too has helped pushed me forward with my recovery. Thank you Dr. Roberson for giving me my life back! Never take mobility for granted!

I was having a hard time with my insurance and getting me a referral to a worthwhile doctor. I relate that to you so you get an understanding that I spoke with more than one "expert" before I was placed with Dr. Robertson. She was very detailed when discussing the MRI results, the body's functions and the recovery of those areas. She also discussed multiple recommendations and wanted to know what worked best with my goals and current situation. Even her staff, from the folks that field the phone calls, to the folks at the front desk, to her partner in crime Dr. Jackie impressed me and made me feel comfortable with my care. I had a left hip arthroscopy vs larbral reconstruction done on Sep 26,2018. Today is almost one month out and i have almost my full strength and flexibility back in that area. I should also mention this is my second time having this surgery and my progress hasn't been anticipated as going as well as it is! She did an excellent job. Only criticism is sometimes her prior appointments can run into your time so she comes in late but she gives you her attention while you're in the room and that's more valuable to me than anything.

Dr. Robertson is a great doctor! She is very attentive, explains everything very well and shows MRI images to a patient. I am very pleased with a knee arthroscopy and partial medial meniscectomy surgery that she performed on me. I can return back to my athletic activities now. I highly recommend her as a sports orthopedics doctor.