David Mclntosh's Online Review Report Card
4.4
Average Star Rating
90
Total Reviews
2
Recent Reviews
6
Review Sites Found
Accepts Medicare
--
Medical School
-
Graduation Year
-
Source: data.cms.gov Check DocInfo.Org for any disciplinary action against this provider.
ScoreDoc is affiliated with RepuGen and GMR Web Team. You're welcome to work with them or any provider you choose.
Sentiment Analysis
| Top Entities | Top Positive Key Trend Drivers |
|---|
| Top Entities | Top Negative Key Trend Drivers |
|---|
Sentiment Analysis
Online Reviews Breakdown
List of David Mclntosh's Reviews
Dr McIntosh is a gentleman who really cares for his patients and is great with children I watched him talk with parents regarding their children’s surgery and talking with children in turn. My surgery went well and had no need for pain killers. The staff at the hospital were great and really friendly. I highly recommended this doctor and Northlakes day surgery.
Do not recommend. Was told my child needed surgery, was rude, when asking questions was dismissive and only seemed to care about booking in for surgery. I went for a second opinion and I am VERY glad I did. A decent approachable ENT advised no surgery was required. My child has had no surgery and is doing well.
This man will help millions of people. Couldn't rate him highly enough! Thankyou so much!
Dr. McIntosh has been my doctor for 4 years now. He is caring when it comes to his patients. I drive over an hour to see him for this reason.
I just had my first visit with Dr. McIntosh after losing my previous PCP and I’m so grateful to have been set up with him! Nothing but good things to say about him! He was very thorough with everything during my visit (although I was 10 minutes late). He had bloodwork done for me right on the spot which I’d been long overdue for, called me the next day to tell me my results, and even sent me an email with a copy and further explanation of my results- don’t think I’ve ever had a PCP do that before. He gave me recommendations for specialists for 2 health issues I was concerned about and had a nurse call me to set up appointments with them. I’m so pleased with my experience and I highly recommend Dr. McIntosh! Thank you!
Overall - we are grateful our sons surgery went well. I cannot comment on the ability of Dr McIntosh as a surgeon - as I am not a medical professional. I do know that he is very experienced, and very confident in this surgery. I can only comment on our experiences with him before and after the surgery. My first impressions were not great. A five minute $220 consultation where we were told my 3yr old would require surgery. After initial observations, Dr McIntosh turned to his computer, printed a surgery referral and said "book this asap". My questions were answered very bluntly and abruptly, so I asked if there were any good resources he recommended for me to refer to if I had further questions. He just suggested I buy his book off Amazon. When I asked about the actual procedure, it was barely explained at all. I was simply told I could worry about the current health implications, or worry about the solution. Dr McIntosh kept turning back to the computer, and not really engaging with us at all - making me feel as though he was rushing us out of the appointment. My gut instinct was to find another surgeon - however he came so highly recommended by our trusted dentist, that I pushed my feelings aside, and assured myself that his confidence was a good sign and that it meant he was extremely capable and skilled at this surgery. The staff at the hospital (SCU private) prior to booking were amazing. One thing that we would have liked done differently (this is for the hospital, not the surgeon) is a bit more of an idea of surgery time vs admission time. Eg. We were admitted at 10am, but surgery wasn't until 1pm. It would have been helpful to know, so we didn't fast a 3yr old unnecessarily longer than needed. Our "meeting the surgeon" beforehand was him walking around the waiting area, asking everyone to sign consent forms and saying "any questions" as he moved to the next person. After surgery, Dr McIntosh came around the recovery ward, and was a bit more approachable and willing to answer questions and give advice for recovery. On day 6 my son had a bleed, and was taken via ambulance to QCH. We understand that these things happen, and the reason is unknown - so definitely do not blame anyone for it. We did find it odd however, that everyone at the hospital (QCH) did not believe us when we said we were denied a script for anything stronger than paracetamol or ibuprofen, as their standard is to send parents home after surgery with the above, as well as a stronger pain relief. My friend's son (same age) had the exact same surgery on the same day at North West Private, and was provided with a script for stronger pain relief if required. I'm not a medical professional, and I'm sure Dr McIntosh has his own reasons and research for not providing stronger releif. - but did think it was a bit strange that everyone else seemed to recommend having a stronger medication on standby.
Do not recommend! 5min consultation with us, scared 5yo boy and this Dr had no bedside manner or patience for my son. $220 for consultation and when I went to call his office the next day to book surgery they requested up front payment of our PH excess and gap!!! After forking out $220 the day before!! Would not let me a book a date in for surgery until I could pay all costs. I booked another consultation with a more reputable ENT that specialises in Peadiatrics and have now been told surgery is not even required for my son.
Cannot fault Dr McIntosh. Thank you for working with us to make surgery and treatment possible. I full faith in your ability. I was recommended to you by our family dentist and as a health care professional myself I know that this would only occur if you offered quality and expert advice and treatment.
Disappointing to say the least. Please reconsider before having your surgery with Dr McIntosh. My 2 year old son had his tonsils and adenoids removed by Dr McIntosh in the Sunshine Coast Private Hospital, only to have a second surgery days later in the public hospital to remove remaining adenoid tissue. Despite the public hospital ENT team contacting Dr McIntosh, I have not heard from Dr McIntosh to check on my sons’ condition or to discuss why there was missed adenoid tissue that resulted in a second unnecessary surgery. I had one phone call from Dr McIntosh the first surgery night and a phone call from his office staff a week after the original surgery. They seemed oblivious to the circumstances. I told them what had happened, and the response seemed scripted and that was that they would make a note on the file and to make sure I keep on top of the pain medication. There was no duty of care and I cannot stress this enough….. there are many other professional doctors to consider before choosing Dr McIntosh, find another Doctor.
I really wouldn’t recommend Dr McIntosh. Our appointments were quick (yet costly) with brief discussions and assessment, and with bare minimum medical explanation of the procedure being proposed. I was unimpressed that I wasn’t actually asked what I might like to decide to do, rather told to go ahead with surgery.
Did you find this reputation scorecard helpful?
Locations
No related location
Selection Criteria
All the information you see here is based on our analysis of internet reviews across the seven major review platforms most used by consumers during their healthcare provider selection. The platforms we selected are Google, WebMD, Yelp, HealthGrades, Facebook, RateMDs, and Vitals. The analysis algorithm uses the compiled data of average score, recency of reviews, number of reviews, and the sentiment expressed in the written comments. It then assigns weight to each parameter based on the available research on how consumers use reviews in their doctor selection process. This report is designed to help identify the doctors with the best overall review score in an area and does not reflect the doctors' competence.
Disclaimer
We recognize the importance of reviews in your selection of a healthcare provider. While we strive to make the information on this report as accurate as possible, ScoreDoc makes no claims, promises, or guarantees about the accuracy, completeness, or adequacy of the contents of this report and is not liable for errors and omissions in the materials. ScoreDoc works with a 3rd party to collect data for generating this report. We encourage you to review the report for accuracy by visiting individual review platforms of doctors of interest based on their overall review score. We suggest you consider this report as initial input and independently verify all info before deciding on your healthcare provider.
Google
WebMD
Yelp
HealthGrades
Facebook
RateMDs
Vitals
