John T. Carroll Md's Online Review Report Card

I saw Dr. Carroll for most of my second pregnancy with no major issues until he became defensive and hostile with me at 37 weeks when I asked about his office’s masking policy during COVID (after two staff were unmasked or not fully masked in proximity to patient areas). When, after a fairly unproductive conversation where he did nothing to reassure me or make sure I felt safe in his office, I eventually started crying and said I needed to leave, he berated me for “harming my baby” if I “stormed out”. While upset, I did not storm out and I am still in shock that he would treat a patient so badly, especially one in late pregnancy. Now, I am faced with finding a new doctor with 3 weeks till my due date. I feel extremely let down by his lack of professionalism and profound lack of compassion or empathy.

Dr. Carroll is an amazing, caring man. He takes the time to answer whatever questions you have and never makes you feel like you are just a number. Would highly recommend to anyone.

Dr. Carroll was recommended to me for a VBAC. I loved how he spends the time with you doing the ultrasounds himself and checks babies heartbeat himself. Very individualized and personable care. Always treated me with respect. Very calm and patient.

We had a confirmed procedure scheduled on a Tuesday morning at CDH. My wife and I took a day off work to attend this. We drove 40 minutes to get there and signed in. 5 minutes after the appointment was supposed to start we were informed he had an emergency and could not do the appointment. Understand emergencies but no one from his office had the courtesy to notify us (maybe incompetent or perhaps just apathetic). Regardless, we will be looking for a different doctor closer to home.

Dr. Carroll is an amazing doctor and a wonderful man. He delivered 2 of my children and was present for most of my labor (8 hours) as well as the delivery. He is pro-active and an expert with complications that arise during pregnancy and delivery--I experienced both. He NEVER rushes you and listens to all your concerns. My teenage daughter also consults with him as her hormones affect her mood. She feels comfortable talking with him about female things, which surprised me a bit.

Dr. Carroll is an excellent doctor! He is very knowledgeable, kind, professional and caring. I would highly recommend him!

Best OB in dupage county

I cannot say enough good things about Dr. Carroll. After being told that I would probably have to deliver my twins by c-section, I switched OB's and starting going to Dr. Carroll. It was the best decision I made for my pregnancy. He not only let me try to deliver vaginally, but he safely delivered my son (baby b) breach. He let me know that I have options and was willing to give it our best shot. I'm so glad I found him. He is kind, and very knowledgeable. His nurses are wonderful!

I cannot say enough good things about Dr. Carroll. After being told that I would probably have to deliver my twins by c-section, I switched OB's and starting going to Dr. Carroll. It was the best decision I made for my pregnancy. He not only let me try to deliver vaginally, but he safely delivered my son (baby b) breach. He let me know that I have options and was willing to give it our best shot. I'm so glad I found him. He is kind, and very knowledgeable. He is not one to push a C-section, and is willing to do whatever he can to help you have a safe delivery. His nurses are so kind. I highly recommend Dr. Carroll.

2014 he pressured me and lied saying my baby would be stuck if I didn't have c section. This was my 5th child and I told him from beginning that I drag to dilate but of course after 11 hours he wants to cut me open worst experience ever on top of that my son had to be treated in nicu for fluid in lungs.Nevr use him unless u have short labors and dialate supper fast. He should retire already!!!!