Keith Holley's Online Review Report Card

I had an appointment with Dr Holly, he sent his PA in to tell me that my knee was fine. Turns out he never even looked at my MRI! The referring dr had to visit with Dr Holly to get him to take my case seriously! I have no confidence in this Dr.

Had hip replaced by Dr. Holly in 2017. Had intense pain in THIGH immediately after surgery that has continued even to today. The hip feels fine, but the pain has continually gotten worse. After 3 re-visits and x-rays, Dr. Holly said there was nothing wrong, nothing to do, and said the pain would go away. Yesterday, my Dr. that just replaced my right hip, looked closely at my left thigh, and found that when the left hip was replaced, one of the screws was inserted incorrectly, penetrated the iliopsoas tendon and almost hit the femoral artery. The tendon is what has been causing pain and we are determining how to remedy the screwed up screw. Thanks, Dr. Holly for making the last five years pure hell.

Thrilled to be pain free. Staff was friendly, hospital was great, PA was very helpful, I really can't say enough good things about my experience. I hope I never need another joint replacement but if I do I won't let anyone talk me out of surgery again, I will be talking to Dr. Holley right away!

Great surgeon, awesome guy

Feeling anxious about surgery is normal. Dr. Keith Holley gave me confidence, told what to expect before, during and after my hip replacement surgery. He explained what he would do to permanently relieve my hip pain, and he has done that. He told me what I should do so my surgery and recovery would be relatively pain-free, and it has been. Everything Dr. Holley said was true—he is honest, tremendously skilled (Board-certified) in the latest procedures, and restored me to a life free from pain—a life worth living. If fear is holding you back, please put your trust in Dr. Holley, his team and the nurses at Treasure Valley Hospital. Physician-owned hospitals provide the highest quality of patient care in America. My nurses were friendly, caring, quick to respond, always helpful; the private room was quiet, comfortable; food is fresh, better than many restaurants. Please share your concerns with Dr. Holley, trust him, have the surgery so you can enjoy a full, healthy life again!

I'm very grateful that when I needed a hip replacement Dr. Holley was insistently recommended by a friend who is a nurse. She was right! Pre-surgery anxiety was minimal because Dr. Holley had been so informative. Post-surgery checkups were complete and reassuring. The surgery itself was a success and I'm no longer plagued by pain. At six months, my Life Quality is so drastically improved and I can walk, stride, sleep with no pain now. I was so comfortable with Dr. Holley personally and had full confidence which was entirely warranted. He is very skilled and professional. And, I believe, a good man. Also - my surgery was at Treasure Valley Hospital and I cannot recommend that enough! The patient/caregiver ratio is so much more favorable than other area hospital. Overall, my surgery was a very good experience in every aspect.

Outstanding. Very professional and candid. I strongly recommend him. He did a pair of hip replacements for me. His office staff did everything they said they would, and on time as expected

Dr. Holley and his staff were very professional and intelligent. I had a total knee replacement on my right knee and will be returning to have my left knee replace upon completing rehab of my right knee.

I have had a great experience with Dr Holly and I have great trust and faith in him. His open and honest approach was greatly appreciated!!

He did my knee replacement and he did an excellent job; minimal recovery time, low pain during recovery, and a perfectly functioning, pain-free knee now. Highly recommend him for a knee procedure. Not the most "warm and fuzzy" personality, but very professional. And it's results that matter.