Carroll John T Md Obstetrics & Gynecology's Online Review Report Card

BAD BILLING EXPERIENCE. I don’t know why Dr Carrol decides to have a 3rd party billing company but I am being billed for Dr Carrol’s services that he didn’t perform he was out of town for my sons delivery so a doctor from the hospital delivered my son. They billed and COLLECTED from my insurance. I spoke with this billing lady months ago she laughed at her mistake and said she would fix it and today I’m still being billed for a delivery he was not present for and bills I already paid Northwestern for. Unfortunately the care of the practice also includes billing and I am beyond disappointed with the hoops I have to go through to get this taken care of.

Do yourself a favor and make Dr. Carroll your obgyn! He is kind, compassionate and wonderful at what he does! He is very experienced and knowledgeable about a whole array of feminine health concerns and he is the doctor who will make sure you are healthy and enjoying life! After my unfortunate non viable fetus experience elsewhere I came to him for a second opinion. I will never forget his comment to me as I tried not to sob for the loss of my dream baby: "no one should ever tell you to smile right now because this is a terrible loss, but when you are ready,please know that your smile lights up the world!" He was so sweet 💗

This doctor was recommended to me by a friend and boy am I glad! I had one beautiful baby before I saw Dr. Carroll, but afterwards a pregnancy that was not viable. He was so kind and compassionate with me! I will never forget that. I am happy to return each year for the same dedication and care for my health and well being :)

Dr Carroll has taken care of me since I was 16, delivered all of my children & will be delivering my last child in June. I wouldn’t go to any other Dr but him. Known him going on 10 years & I hope he never retires!

They are holding my records hostage. I've called everyday for a week. I am high risk and cannot make another appointment with a different OB until they release my records. All I want to do is have a consult with a female OB, why am I being treated this way? They have ghosted me & all this man has to do is sign his initials to release my paperwork. Who operates like this? This is the worst doctor & most incompetent staff I've ever come across. Do not book here, there are many more issues I have with this office. Run far away.

They are holding my records hostage. I’ve called everyday for a week. I am high risk and cannot make another appointment with a different OB until they release my records. All I want to do is have a consult with a female OB, why am I being treated this way? They have ghosted me & all this man has to do is sign his initials to release my paperwork. Who operates like this? This is the worst doctor & most incompetent staff I’ve ever come across. Do not book here, there are many more issues I have with this office. Run far away.

I have been a patient of Dr. Carroll's for over 6 years now. He is knowledgeable, straight forward (which I appreciate), listens to all my concerns and takes all possible options into account. The staff at his office are always helpful and they truly care about your health. After being diagnosed with infertility, Dr. Carroll reached out and got me an appointment with a fertility specialist in 2 weeks time when the wait time for new patient's was over 8 months.

Delivered my first baby and he found out that I had cholestasis and took every precaution to make sure me and my baby were healthy!

If you are a patient who does not think for themselves and does not want a doctor who thinks critically about your care then this is a doctor for you. As soon as you display the tiniest hint of self advocacy and expectation of actually listening to you and your individual needs this practice will try to intimidate you and gaslight you.

Dr. Carroll is phenomenal. I have met no one like him in all my years of experience with medical professionals. Even though I transferred to his practice late in my first pregnancy looking for a non-C-section happy OB, Dr Carroll is not simply a “naturalist” but a pragmatic, highly experienced, straight-shooting, and caring professional and person. I transferred to his care due to concerns about unnecessary medical interventions at my prior OB practice (and subsequently found out that my former OB actually said “off the record” that she would perform a C-section at every delivery if possible!). His orientation towards letting the body do what it does best but not buying into every natural myth (delivery was formerly one of the most dangerous experiences for women in every century before this one, after all) allowed me to ultimately trust his judgment at every crucial point in our delivery. Since having two sons (without pain meds but with some “interventions,” like puncturing the bag of waters when we hadn’t progressed past 9 cm for a few hours), I can say I honestly would try to have another baby sooner if I thought he was going to retire soon. He is the least awkward for discussing uncomfortable subjects, never in a rush, encourages all your questions and listens to concerns but is not reticent about his hard-earned perspective on delivery “fads” (e.g. recommending petocin post-delivery to minimize the chance of hemorrhage but ultimately allowing my decision to forgo it, but not budging on the requirement that I have a fetal heart rate monitor at all times when laboring in the hospital so as to ensure my baby was not at risk). While I agree that sometimes his staff (reception in particular - not his nurses) seem brusque or overworked, there’s no price you can put on having a medical professional in your corner, whose judgment you can trust when the chips are down.