Nicole Cataldi's Online Review Report Card

Dr. Cataldi was the best person I could have had to deliver my son. I’m surprised to see other people having any issues. My son was born in October of 2017. He was 3 1/2 weeks early. I’ve already met all 5 of the team (cataldi has a team with other doctors) so I was comfortable with all of them already. My water had to be broken and I was givin an epidural (by my choosing) and my sons heart rate dropped dramatically. The entire team stepped in immediately and Dr. Cataldi calmly told me what was happening as she rushed me to emergency Surgery. I had an emergency C-section that day. And everything was clear and informative from Dr. Cataldi. She saved my babies life and I am eternally greatful. She will be delivering my second this coming up year.

Dr. Cataldi has been there for me in my darkest moments and proudest days. She goes out of her way to make sure that you are taken care of. I could not recommend her enough. The only reason I gave 4 stars is because I feel the office is unorganized and I wish they used MyChart.

If you’re skinny and white, she’s nice. However, if you’re a woman of color and plus size-it’s a different story. She fat shamed me, told me how big i was, and said it’s “disgusting to see young people so big”. I do need to lose weight, and I am working on it now, but I lost both of my parents in a car crash, so things have been tough for me. She has a terrible bedside manner. It’s not what you say, but how you say things. She was so rude to me and talked down to me that I left the appointment in tears. So heads up, if you’re plus size, I would rethink seeing Dr. Cataldi.

Dr Cataldi is amazing!!! Very compassionate and very thorough! After she heard my story she wasted no time in helping me. I cannot thank you enough Dr Cataldi!!! Absolutely amazing. And the nursing staff at saint Anthony’s was just as amazing while I was in recovery! Im so blessed that I have her as my doctor now. Thank you Dr Cataldi. Thank you so so much!!

Amazing doctor. If it wasn't for Doctor Cataldi's quick actions when delivering my son I wouldn't be celebrating his 1st birthday. She always made sure I was 100% and never rushed me or my husband when we were asking question and question. Staff was always respectful and kind. Great place!!

All the employees there were rude and disrespectful I’m in the middle of having a miscarriage and they refused to see me.

I had to have blood work drawn and the nurse didn’t even wear any gloves. She also didn’t even stick the needle in my vein right she had to have someone else come in and do it for her. I’m in the middle of a miscarriage and they didn’t really even seem to care.

I’m 47 with 3 grown children and she is the best, most thorough Gyno Dr I’ve met regarding a first time patient and female wellness check. Five+ stars.

I am literally in tears right now. I am currently 17 weeks pregnant and I've been seeing Dr. Cataldi since I was about 6 weeks. Everyone is aware that you are suppose to see the OB every fours weeks and my last appointment was 10-2-18. My Secondary insurance (not my primary) changed to Healthy Indiana Plan (which the office does not take) which led the office to tell me they cant see me anymore. OK. I have been without an OB for a month now trying to find someone in my network. After weeks of searching I finally found an OB that can see me November 23, 2018 (which is a bit far away). I scheduled that appointment and looked to get ONE more appointment from Dr. Cataldi's , which my new OB suggested. Dr. Cataldi's office staff refused to schedule me, due to my insurance, they say. They told me " IT WAS ILLEGAL to schedule you knowing we don't take your insurance". I was desperate, I even told them I would pay the cash fee of $100.00....They still refused to see me. I am so hurt because doctor is aware that I am suffering extreme depression and have been prescribed to antidepressants due to being suicidal in the beginning of my pregnancy. I Loved seeing Dr. Cataldi but I will not be referring anyone to this office because of the discrimination I felt today. To deny a pregnant patient who was willing to pay out of pocket to care for her and her child is wrong. I hate I did not catch her name but I spoke to head of billing, Rachel or something. I pray my unborn child and I will be ok but shame on you.

Doctor Cataldi wasn't the problem.Her Assistant was.. Her name is Sheryl.She's a Midwife Nurse. Doctor Cataldi had been put of the office, and they put Sheryl in charge of one of our appointments. Sheryl had ask me if I had been checkingy sugar fory gestational diabetes. I said yes but I haven't in a week because I forgot my sugar monitor when I was on vacation out of town. She told me that my baby was gonna die. Trying to instill fear into me, and my husband. My sugar levels we're normal, and had been for the month! She was very bossy, and bulling us. We stayed pretty calm, but told the staff we didn't want to see her again. They said they would make a note of it. Then when I went into labor with my son.. She came to the hospital to deliver him! She stood over my bed, and yelled.. "Are you even in Pain!?"With her hands on her hips. I thought the Devil walked through the Door! He did!I said No Ma'am! You are not delivering my son. Where is my Doctor? She said "I'm the only one on call!" I said you are not delivering my son! She walked put the door stomping. Angry.. She's very very unprofessional..I feel very sorry for these women under her care 😢😢😢