Mahmoud Nagib's Online Review Report Card

Dr. Nagib was very understanding and very helpful with all 4 of my neck surgeries. I have a degenerative bone disorder. Dr. Nagib also is so knowledgeable and willing to take the time to explain everything to you in normal terms not all the medical terminology which can get confusing. I highly recommend him.

Dr. Nagib is a brilliant surgeon. My family member needed to have a brain tumor removed and everyone I told about the need for surgery said some version of, “I hope Dr. Nagib is your surgeon; he’s the best!” We now understand what they meant. We had a a total resection with no residual impact to functioning.

I had surgery by Dr Nagib. He took a lot of time to explain my condition and answer my many questions. He’s VERY skilled at what he does and he has years of experience . I felt comfortable with him instantly. My surgery went well, I am thankful every day that I found him!

Dr Nagib is fantastic. Everyone on his team is fantastic. I have nothing bad to say and am so happy that I chose to have my 3rd surgery with him. He fixed it all and I am forever grateful for his kindness and compassion he showed me. Thank you for everything you do, you are truely a wonderful human being.

I was referred to Dr Nagib by my family doctor and am so happy I chose to have my surgery done here. He is a great surgeon. His team is also very good at what they do. I've had 2 other spine surgeries at different places and this one was by far the most enjoyable experience. Thank you so much Dr Nagib!!

This guy needs to retire. He was trained in the 70's and has not kept up with state of the art modalities and my outcomes suffered from it. He performed a routine lumbar discectomy/laminotomy in 2015 on me using an open approach because I "was not a candidate for minimally invasive approaches." I was left with permanent neuro deficit which has negatively affected my quality of life greatly. He knew it within hours of recovery and down played it. I have since consulted with other surgeons who have more experience with microscopic/endoscopic approaches who would have treated using such approaches. After many years of pain and transient radiculopathy I am scheduled for a redo procedure to clean up this mess Nagib created. Again, this guy needs to retire.

These people actively and purposefully discriminate based on genetic disabilities, even though it's illegal.They even sent me a letter stating that they automatically deny millions of EDS patients access to care with any of their providers solely due to the patients having a genetic condition that directly causes our disabilities.Their letter then demands EDS patients go to a facility that is well-documented to be extremely abusive towards us, and who they know abused me and withheld life-saving medical care from me.They've repeatedly treated me as nothing but a case study to be ignored and thrown away rather than a human being who deserves to live. That's obscene.

Absent with bad staff.

Dr. Nagib is absolutely fantastic. I read some of these reviews beforehand and was riddled with anxiety. I thought he would be cold and rude. He was so kind and welcoming. He performed a lumbar laminectomy on me 4/21. I was up and walking within 4 hours and off narcotics within 4 days. Many other surgeons require their patients to lay flat for days. My scar is barely noticeable and my pain is gone. I cannot thank him enough and highly recommend him. Oh! His one nurse kinda sucks but that’s not his fault. He didn’t hire her. His PA is great too. They’re a solid team. You’ll be in great hands with them.

Nagib is a highly skilled neurosurgeon, he has been practicing for many years. However, don't expect to see him personally other than before surgery or if a decision needs to be escalated in order to have surgery. Nagib is great with cases that tend to follow textbook, depending on what your condition is, he may be a great fit, he has performed some complex surgeries. But some conditions, he sticks to textbook symptoms and will only act until symptoms become life-threatening. While I can't recommend him based on past experiences with him, he is good at what he does if you are not an outlier of your condition.