Thomas Amalfitan's Online Review Report Card
Thomas Amalfitan
4.2
Average Star Rating
43
Total Reviews
0
Recent Reviews
4
Review Sites Found
Accepts Medicare
--
Medical School
-
Graduation Year
-
Source: data.cms.gov Check DocInfo.Org for any disciplinary action against this provider.
ScoreDoc is affiliated with RepuGen and GMR Web Team. You're welcome to work with them or any provider you choose.
Review Summary
Dr. Amalfitano received 86.0% positive feedback, with patients praising the successful surgeries and thorough explanations. However, 14.0% of the feedback was negative, primarily citing dismissive behavior, lack of attention, and incomplete diagnoses. Overall, while valued for surgical expertise, the practice needs better patient communication and empathy.ScoreDoc Score
Sentiment Analysis
| Top Entities | Top Positive Key Trend Drivers |
|---|
| Top Entities | Top Negative Key Trend Drivers |
|---|
Sentiment Analysis
Online Reviews Breakdown
WebMD
Yelp
Facebook
RateMDs
List of Thomas Amalfitan's Reviews
Dr. Amalfitano has been super ot work with my very bad knees. He's been thorough in investigating and explained things to me so I understood what was needed and what he expected with trying to do a double knee replacement. He wouldn't do the surgery until my overall health was in good order--showing he wasn't just pushing ahead , even if I wasn't physically able to handle the surgery needed. Fantastic surgeon!
Reviewed On HealthGrades
Excellent Work and Provider
Reviewed On Vitals
Dr Amalfitano knows exactly how to make you feel better. He is one of the best surgeons I’ve met.
Reviewed On HealthGrades
I had an outstanding experience. I had Knee surgery. A year ago I could not walk 10 minutes with out having to sit down and get off my knee. Thanks to Dr. Amalfitano I can walk almost as well as I did prior to injury. I am in therapy now and well on my way to full recovery.
Reviewed On HealthGrades
Saw this person for three months. Very condescending, does not listen. Kept telling me I was fine didnt even know why I was there nothing wrong. Refused to listen about pain level, left me in boot from emergency room. After three months of no help I went to a real orthopedic dr who thru an MRI found out I had two broken major bones, a torn ligament and nerve damage. Thankfully I choose to leave Mr Amalfitano's care when I did before further damage was done. He never seemed to listen or care about my symptoms of pain, I often felt mocked after an appointment.
Reviewed On Google
Outpatient knee replacement went great. Very minimal pain which could be controlled by tylenol.
Reviewed On Google
A very good dr. I had no problems with my hip replacement.
Reviewed On Google
Stated multiple times that he “didn’t know why I was there” and that my issue was my neck, not my shoulder, like my PCP had diagnosed and referred me to him for. He was in the room for less than five minutes, referring me out to someone else. Had no problem charging my insurance and sending me a bill for something I “shouldn’t have been there” for though.
Reviewed On HealthGrades
I saw Amalfitano for three months. So thankful that I finally left to seek real help. I felt ignored, mocked and talked down to at my appointments. Was in great pain for three months and Amalfitano kept saying I dont even know why you are here. Finally I agreed with him and found a real orthopedic dr who found out in one week of seeing him that I had two major broken bones in my ankle, a torn ligament and nerve damage. So for three months Amalfitano didnt help me left me in the boot from the emergency room and mocked me at every appointment. Amalfitano wasted my time and money while providing no care. Dont recommend and wont be back.
Reviewed On Vitals
I went for a second opinion, foot, ankle & knee pain. Without looking at me, he said he agreed with his colleague. I asked further questions and he said he had flat feet and he stood all day, his feet didn't hurt, so mine shouldn't either. If I expected any help, which would be unlikely, I'd need to go to Baltimore. But he doubted they would be able to help with my feet. Arch supports would be my only options. (like I didn't know that on my own?) HE was the knee specialist and never looked at that my knee. (previous total knee replacement by a now retired surgeon.) I'll be finding a new practice. I felt belittled. He was smug and I felt he was rude.
Reviewed On Vitals
Did you find this reputation scorecard helpful?
Locations
No related location
Download ScoreDoc App for Safe Report Storage
Selection Criteria
All the information you see here is based on our analysis of internet reviews across the seven major review platforms most used by consumers during their healthcare provider selection. The platforms we selected are Google, WebMD, Yelp, HealthGrades, Facebook, RateMDs, and Vitals. The analysis algorithm uses the compiled data of average score, recency of reviews, number of reviews, and the sentiment expressed in the written comments. It then assigns weight to each parameter based on the available research on how consumers use reviews in their doctor selection process. This report is designed to help identify the doctors with the best overall review score in an area and does not reflect the doctors' competence.
Disclaimer
We recognize the importance of reviews in your selection of a healthcare provider. While we strive to make the information on this report as accurate as possible, ScoreDoc makes no claims, promises, or guarantees about the accuracy, completeness, or adequacy of the contents of this report and is not liable for errors and omissions in the materials. ScoreDoc works with a 3rd party to collect data for generating this report. We encourage you to review the report for accuracy by visiting individual review platforms of doctors of interest based on their overall review score. We suggest you consider this report as initial input and independently verify all info before deciding on your healthcare provider.
