Randal Paniello's Online Review Report Card

Dr. Paniello is a wonderful surgeon as well as kind physician. He's performed several surgeries on me, always makes sure he answers all questions, gives options, and lets me decide how to proceed. Excellent bedside manner.

Horrible Doctor! Was not prepared for my appointment even though my previous doctor sent him all of my medical documentation. Was not helpful in my consultation. Ultimately, had to get a PET scan done and was never even given a phone call about my results or scheduled for a follow up appointment. I had to reach out to them the entire time. Horrible person to deal with and could care less about his patients.

I waited 1 hour & 20 minutes for my post op appointment & I didn't even get to the back patient rooms. There were 2 patients still ahead of me when I inquired at the front desk. Which means the wait would have been astronomical. I ended up leaving & missed my post op appointment. No one communicated with me or communicated with the other patients in the waiting room regarding the delay. We were not given the opportunity to reschedule. If I showed up for my appointment this late, would I have been seen? Probably not. Very poorly run office. Wouldn't recommend this practice.

He explained the scope to me when I asked. The appointment did not feel rushed. He answered all my questions.

This doctor is heaven sent he talked and explain everything to me before I went to surgery his staff nurses and team were so courteous loving and kind towards me and my family they came and talked to me after surgery I left the hospital without a scar no pain I didn’t even know I had been cut this doctor did an awesome job and I would recommend him to others when I asked him do he pray before he do the procedures and he said yes he ask God to guide his hand he did a remarkable tremendous job

I wish I could give him less stars! He completely botched my surgery and he was always arrogant... talking about his latest degree he was in school for. Maybe focus on being a doctor and less on astrology? Oh and be prepared for his residents to do 85% of the work on you. I'm more than certain this is why I wasn't grounded on the table before surgery and in turn got electrocuted.

Fantastic Dr & fantastic man! 4.5 years out of treatment for squamous cell carcinoma cancer. Now graduated away from Dr. Paniello to Melissa Protell PA & in very good hands with her. Every one that treated me at Barns Jewish & Siteman Cancer Center are top notch & personable. I was in the right place. Thank you!

Seems that he makes useless appointments, we have to travel 4 to 5 hours for an appointment then to be told that he does not have all the records he needs or just visits with patient and sends on our way some of this could have been done with a phone call. Then he tells us that have to have other appointments with other doctors for treatment when these should have been scheduled at the same time as his useless appointment this is extremely tiring on the patient as well as people transporting him.I'm sure he is a good Doctor but sure don't take patient into consideration as far a travel

For more than 10 yrs now the right side of my tongue has been paralyzed from having an operation by Randall C Paniello after a dentist bruised my nerve from an injection. I finally spoke with him about a year ago to see if he could reconnect the nerve that he seperated his answer was no you can not and why he recommended an operation to remove more nerve he said it was like an electrical wire that when it touches it arcs, in reality your nerves are supposed to be connected. After meeting with him years later he denied everything. He said I told him I wanted my tongue numb. Also I asked him if he had ever performed this operation before his answer was no. Which tells me he had no idea of the after effects of this operation.

I have been a patient of Dr Paniello's for years, wouldn't Trust anyone else with my condition