David Edelstein's Online Review Report Card

I have never been so horribly treated by a medical practice. I was referred to a doctor at 6010 Bay Parkway for hand surgery to remove a ganglion cyst. It takes me an hour to get to this office. At that consultation, I was referred to dr edelstein to have it removed. I had to have another consultation with him before the surgery, which meant adding an extra 2 hour round trip. At the consultation, the doctor refused to remove the ganglion cyst. I asked twice, and he told me he would not remove it. I left the office, because I should not have to argue for a normal treatment for something that is causing me pain, and affecting my ability to work. Avoid this doctor.

Thank you doctor you are very friendly and professional ❤️

An amazing doctor. Wonderful bedside manner, compassionate, kind and all around perfect. There is usually a very short wait, the staff is respectful. Always an exceptional experience with Dr. Edelstein. Highly recommend to everyone!

Dr. Edelstein is amazing nothing but positive things from scheduling an appointment to the day of surgery, it was a positive experience. Snowboarding accident cause me to fracture my wrist it was my first time breaking a bone however Dr. Edelstein is incredibly knowledgeable and advise me of my options. Surgery was quick to schedule and my wrist has healed back to normal. Highly recommend Dr. Edelstein he cares about his patients and makes you feel welcome.

Very Friendly And Straight To The Point, No Nonsense Doctor. Tells You How It Is And Recommends The Best Option Moving Forward. Would Extremely Recommend If You Want The Best Possible Recovery.

Disappointing appointment with Dr Edelstein ( hand surgeon). Appointment was rushed! He introduced himself and his very next words were that he would not do a revision surgery without discussing my prior history. Offered very little in terms of how I should proceed if he did not want to do surgery. Took elbow x ray and did not offer the results. Clearly can find better hand surgeons who show more interest in providing useful information and concern. The reception area is chaotic and better organization is needed.

Beyond compare

Dr. Edelstein is an Excellent doctor. He takes his time to listen to his patients, and offers plenty of options. I recently had a surgery with him which was very successful. I would definitely recommend Dr. Edelstein to family and friends.

Saw Dr Edelstein at the Bay Parkway location for tendonitis on my wrist. He gave me a cortisone shot to “relieve the pain”. His shot caused a pointy like bump on the side of my wrist which I would have accepted had the pain disappeared…instead the pain on my wrist increased tremendously to the point that I couldn’t even pick up my cell phone without being in tears. When I called the office to follow up, I was told that he was on vacation and to take ibuprofen even though it didn’t help. My wrist was visibly swollen and warm to the touch for several weeks. I decided to go to a different Dr (this time from NYU Langone) who gave me another injection…the pain was reduced by 70% within the fist few minutes. Two weeks later the pain was completely gone. I wouldn’t recommend Edelstein to anyone. He may be “nice” but nice doesn’t help heal the pain. He can’t even give a cortisone injection correctly. Go to someone who knows what they are doing.

I’ve been to multiple doctors for an unknown injury on my wrist, no swelling no bruising. 2 doctors gave my cortisone shots, didn’t help. I’ve been dealing with this pain for 1 year. I was recommended this doctor, after him looking at my hand for 5 mins he scheduled me for surgery. I was in desperate need to relive my pain, he said it was tendinitis and the surgery will relieve my pain. 4 months later I’m in more pain then before my surgery. When back to him twice he kept stating physical therapy will fix it, however I’ve been going to therapy for a year straight now and it only aggravated the pain. I went to the doctor that recommended me to see this doctor, got an MRI. The mri showed two different tendons swollen then before. We called him to inform of the MRI. He told my mom that it’s my anxiety that’s causing my pain, and said it’s all emotional. I’m currently still in pain and feeling hopeless.!