Anna Rothstein's Online Review Report Card

Highly recommended! Dr. Rothstein & her staff are professional, Friendly and kind. Very trusting and caring practice.

I found Dr Rothstein to be someone who was honest, trustworthy, and reasonable. I felt no pressure to have any surgeries; quite the opposite. She did an excellent job fixing my eyelid. I felt the entire office is very professional and well run.

I was left disfigured after an eyelid surgery with Dr. Rothstein. My eye is noticeably asymmetric now, has visible scarring, the lid is swollen, and it doesn’t close fully. Please think long and hard before having a surgery with her and without a second opinion. My life has never been the same.

My eyelid function and facial appearance is ruined after surgery with Dr. Rothstein. There was a much easier non surgical fix for my medical issue which she did not recommend over invasive methods. A surgeon should also know when NOT to operate. I do not think Dr. Rothstein knows when to be conservative and this, as well as poor surgical technique, is a danger to patients under her care.

Dr. Rothstein is very kind, calm, and knowledgeable. She takes the time to talk to you and explain procedures. The office is inviting and runs smoothly. Everyone is friendly and helpful, and I felt very welcome and comfortable. I’d highly recommend Dr. Rothstein.

Dr. Rothstein and her staff are amazing. They were very professional and friendly to me during a very stressful time. I had to have eyelid surgery on both eyes and she did a phenomenal job. I am only a month out from the procedure and the incision lines are barely visible. I am very grateful for her and her staff. They are the best!

Dr. Rothstein did my upper eyelid surgery. I look so much younger. She is an amazing person, very professional, and I would highly recommend her to anyone. The team effort of the staff of this practice was remarkable. I received top notch quality medical care.

I was referred to Dr. Rothstein for an eyelid lift by my internist. Her bedside manner is wonderful and she has a gentle touch. Her skills as a surgeon is everything I hoped for. Not only is my vision improved, but my eyes don’t feel heavy anymore or like they want to close, and I look so much better. I am extremely happy with Dr. Rothstein and I recommend her to everyone!

I had an eyelid surgery performed with Dr. Rothstein. The post-op result was near complete, and permanent loss of all lashes, inability to fully close my eye due to an irregular lid margin, and noticeable asymmetry in my 20s. I was not told preoperatively that lash loss or inability to close my eye fully were risks. This was particularly distressing because there was a nonsurgical option for management but the surgery was recommended to me nonetheless. After these complications, I saw other oculoplastic surgeons who suggested this outcome should not have occurred. I do not recommend seeing Dr. Rothstein for any surgical care.

Had eye examination with Dr. Rothstein at the Eye Care Center and overall was very impressed. She was very thorough, pleasant and professional. I highly recommend her.