Fifth Avenue Eyecare & Rosenthal Eye Surgery's Online Review Report Card
Fifth Avenue Eyecare & Rosenthal Eye Surgery
4.9
Average Star Rating
337
Total Reviews
21
Recent Reviews
2
Review Sites Found
Accepts Medicare
Yes
Source: data.cms.gov Check DocInfo.Org for any disciplinary action against this provider.
ScoreDoc is affiliated with RepuGen and GMR Web Team. You're welcome to work with them or any provider you choose.
Review Summary
Fifth Avenue EyeCare & Surgery received 95.0% positive feedback, with patients highlighting the doctors' knowledge, caring approach, and the efficient staff. However, 5.0% of the feedback was negative, citing unprofessional staff behavior and questionable surgical outcomes. Overall, the practice is appreciated for its competent care, yet it needs better staff professionalism.ScoreDoc Score
Sentiment Analysis
| Top Entities | Top Positive Key Trend Drivers |
|---|
| Top Entities | Top Negative Key Trend Drivers |
|---|
Sentiment Analysis
Online Reviews Breakdown
Yelp
Facebook
List of Fifth Avenue Eyecare & Rosenthal Eye Surgery's Reviews
Professional and friendly and on time.
Reviewed On Google
Dr Scherk makes the whole trip worth it. She is wonderful, extremely professional, and fun at the same time. She truly takes the time to care for you.
Reviewed On Google
Dr Scherk is terrific, very knowledgeable and efficient. Good staff as well.
Reviewed On Google
Top notch care and office!
Reviewed On Google
Dr. Scherk is knowledgeable and professional. She is thoughtful and really takes time with her patients. She is a gem!
Reviewed On Google
First of all, I feel very grateful to the Lord for having been taking care of my eyes and my cataracts by Dr. Rosenthal. To top it all and needless to say, Dr. Rosenthal treats his patients with compassion and accommodates them with any emergencies they have. No doubt Dr.Rosenthal has the superb experience in his field and I recommend him 100%. May the Lord bless Dr. Rosenthal and his family and his team. Note: DR. ROSENTHAL'S OFFICE IS VERY ACCOMMODATING AND BEAUTIFUL!
Reviewed On Google
This team is incredible—they make my eye care the easiest part of my healthcare. What a breeze—and who would guess?? Look forward to this appointment every year!
Reviewed On Google
Pleasant experience .
Reviewed On Google
Potential patients beware. Dr. Rosenthal is at the end of his useful life as a surgeon and will lie to you to cover up surgical errors when they happen. I had a family member go to him for a lens implantation that became a multi-month saga. Old man Ken installed the lens inside out and took six weeks to realize what he had done before rushing into another traumatic operation. When questioned, he gaslit the patient for scratching their eye and flipping the lens (inside of the eyeball). Apart from the quality of the medical care from Rosenthal, the office staff is highly unprofessional and the office itself is substandard. The office staff made billing mistakes. In the waiting room, we heard them making fun of some of the elderly patients after they left the waiting room. The waiting room smells like urine due to the number of elderly patients they see and lack of cleaning, and there are visible cockroach traps under the furniture with dead roaches. If the above doesn't concern you, take a look at his his hand tremors and ask yourself if this is someone you trust with your vision. Given the options in NYC, you can certainly do better than this place and this doctor. Go to an academic medical center and save yourself the regret.
Reviewed On Google
Dr. Scherk is the best! Friendly and efficient.
Reviewed On Google
Did you find this reputation scorecard helpful?
Locations
No related location
Download ScoreDoc App for Safe Report Storage
Selection Criteria
All the information you see here is based on our analysis of internet reviews across the seven major review platforms most used by consumers during their healthcare provider selection. The platforms we selected are Google, WebMD, Yelp, HealthGrades, Facebook, RateMDs, and Vitals. The analysis algorithm uses the compiled data of average score, recency of reviews, number of reviews, and the sentiment expressed in the written comments. It then assigns weight to each parameter based on the available research on how consumers use reviews in their doctor selection process. This report is designed to help identify the doctors with the best overall review score in an area and does not reflect the doctors' competence.
Disclaimer
We recognize the importance of reviews in your selection of a healthcare provider. While we strive to make the information on this report as accurate as possible, ScoreDoc makes no claims, promises, or guarantees about the accuracy, completeness, or adequacy of the contents of this report and is not liable for errors and omissions in the materials. ScoreDoc works with a 3rd party to collect data for generating this report. We encourage you to review the report for accuracy by visiting individual review platforms of doctors of interest based on their overall review score. We suggest you consider this report as initial input and independently verify all info before deciding on your healthcare provider.
