Joshua D. Stewart's Online Review Report Card

By far one of the best doctors I have ever been to. Incredible bedside manner and fabulous staff. Dr. Stewart takes his time at every appointment, never rushes you and explains the process every step of the way. He is extremely detail oriented and will do a ton of hand holding. If you’re looking for an amazing doctor who actually cares look no further. He’s your guy!!

Great doctor, really cares about his patients, his nursing team is very helpful and kind, I plan to use him again, highly recommended, already recommended him to my friends.

Believe all of the 5-star reviews here, they are 100% accurate! I did want to cover a few aspects in my review that others haven’t touched on as I know that I thoroughly read all reviews when trying to decide on a doctor. This was my second fertility clinic after being a patient at another very well-known practice. I left after spending (wasting) almost a year with them, as the experience was very chaotic, unorganized, and left me feeling like I wasn’t being given the best care. I walked into Dr. Stewart’s Brooklyn office ready to aggressively advocate for myself after having less than stellar care at the aforementioned practice. Turns out that wouldn’t be necessary! Dr. Stewart appeared, a young, fit, attractive doctor – and this threw me off. Where was the old guy with white hair that has spent 30 years helping countless intended parents have babies? I was nervous. Five minutes after speaking with him I realized this was a ridiculous notion – he was so confident and well informed that when I was finished meeting with him, I saw his being a younger doctor to be a complete asset. Up to speed on the latest medical research, comfortable helping patients that perhaps sit outside what used to be considered “traditional” parents. You will see couples and intended hopeful parents of all colors, shapes, and identities in the waiting room, and all are treated with respect and get the very best medical care from Dr Stewart and his team. A VERY important point that I would like to make is that Dr. Stewart and his entire team are Size Friendly. A few years ago, walking through this world as a fit athletic person, I could not have fathomed how important something like this would be. The last few years I have been navigating life as a newly obese individual, which has been challenging and traumatizing in more ways than I would have imagined. My weight has NEVER been an issue here. It has NEVER been highlighted or questioned or made me feel “less than”. With a BMI of 40, many other fertility practices will have limitations for people of my size. Weill Cornell is not one of them. But not only do they “accept” patients that look like me, they offer us the dignity and care that we deserve. They have used a larger blood pressure cuff on my arm without muttering “oh hold on, let me get the bigger one”. Makela is an expert at seamlessly stretching out the tourniquet to wrap it around my sizeable upper arm. They don’t have me weigh in on appointments, or make me feel like they notice me taking a few extra seconds to push myself up on the exam table.. I can’t tell you how much stress this has alleviated from an already emotionally draining journey. I will say, that the “vibe” is different in Dr. Stewart’s Brooklyn office, versus the UES main campus office where you will invariably find yourself on a weekend when you are unable to be seen in BK, or when you need COVID testing, etc. You will find yourself waiting among a sea of women and couples, and can often feel like you are taking a number at a deli counter. That is balanced out by the fact that you know Dr. Stewart is the one reviewing your chart and charged with your care. No matter how harried they are on the UES, you will soon be in the comfort of Makela’s phlebotomy chair, or on Dr. Stewart’s table. Steffan at the front desk is on point, and is a true office professional. He knows the ins and outs of the practice, and is always a resource. The nursing team (Annie/Molly) are wonderful, and answer all questions with unending patience. I will cover the hospital IVF suite nurses/professionals in a separate review, but they are also fabulous and committed to delivering the best care and experience for patients.

Dr Stewart and his team of nurses and staff are exceptional. The entire process was seamless, supportive, and structured extremely clearly from day one. You can always get hold of the team, and everyone is kind to you and understands how sensitive this process and moment is in your life is. I highly recommend Dr Stewart as a brilliant fertility specialist.

Dr. Stewart and his team are wonderful. The front staff and nurses were always so friendly and easy to communicate with. Dr. Stewart was so positive and encouraging throughout my entire journey. He truly cares about his patients and it shows! Although I am happy to be moving forward in my fertility journey, I will miss working with this wonderful team.

On time, pleasant and knowing staff, clean office, overall great experience

To say that Dr. Stewart is an amazing doctor is an understatement!!! He embodies everything you would need and want in a doctor. From my first consultation with Dr. Stewart, I knew my journey into infertility was in great hands. Dr. Stewart is kind, caring, personable and intelligent. I have met with several doctors within Weill Cornell and no one compares to Dr. Stewart’s bedside manner. He doesn’t treat you as just a name on a chart. He gets to know you as a person, not just a patient. Dr. Stewart is also very thorough. I often times leave my appointments with no questions to ask because he answers my questions without me having to even ask. Dr. Stewart is patient, confident and always so positive. He truly makes you feel like a true team. Not only is Dr. Stewart phenomenal, his nursing team is top notch! Makayla, Molly and Annie are always on point and always readily available for anything you may need. They are so supportive and compassionate. If you’re looking for the best infertility doctor in NYC, RUN, don’t walk to see Dr. Stewart and his wonderful team!

Kind, positive but straightforward, and caring with great bedside manner. He makes us feel like we’re all on the same team.

Dr Stewart and his team are really really great! He is very patient, super knowledgeable, kind and always remained positive throughout the whole process! I do not have lots of comparison but from the first visit, he has always inspired me a lot of confidence! Last but not least, his team is great! Molly, Annie and Michaela are literally angels! I do not know how they can be so extremely kind and responsive all the time!

Dr. Stewart and his team are incredibly knowledgeable and helpful. Everyone was kind, helpful, and took the time to answer all of our questions . I would highly recommend Dr. Stewart.