Melinda Smith's Online Review Report Card

Doesn’t listen to concerns and compares herself to your issues. Very self absorbed.

I’ve seen Dr. Smith twice for yearly exams. The first time I had some concerns and shared them with her. She told me I was too young to have such issues and I should lose weight. The second time was just awful. I was scheduled for a pap, which she didn’t even do. I was having several issues and concerns. Again I was told I was too young and to lose weight. She actually told me that my symptoms were my imagination. I asked several questions which she didn’t answer. She just kept repeating herself that I was too young (41) and to lose weight. I never went back. I’ve since been diagnosed with actual issues and I thank God I switched to a doctor who actually cares.

Absolutely the best. Dr. Smith is kind, pernable and patient as well as extremely professional. I would and have recommended her to friends.

If you want to visit a doctor that says completely unethical things, this is the place for you. I once told her that I was feeling pain during a pap smear and she said “This hurts to you but you’re able to have sex?” Made so many other smart remarks regarding unprotected sex (despite being with ONE PERSON for over 3 years), and prescribed me the wrong birth control FOUR (!) times despite my continuous reiteration about needed a specific brand. Makes me never want to visit a gynecologist again and it will for sure never be her. It’s all about the money at this office. My advice: find someone different.

If you want to visit a doctor that says completely unethical things, this is the place for you. I once told her that I was feeling pain during a pap smear and she said “This hurts to you but you’re able to have sex?” Made so many other smart remarks regarding unprotected sex (despite being with ONE PERSON for over 3 years), and prescribed me the wrong birth control FOUR (!) times despite my continuous reiteration about needing a specific brand. Makes me never want to visit a gynecologist again and it will for sure never be her. It’s all about the money at this office. My advice: find someone different.

Excellent staff & Dr! Dr Smith is one of the most caring doctors I have ever been to! She explains everything in great detail & in a manner that I can understand. I do not agree with the negative comments people have left on here!

I did not see Dr. Smith, but I see the other OB/GYN at this office, Jonathan T. Eucker. When I tried to search him on yelp, I got two other addresses- one in Warren and one in Cortland and wasn't sure if it was the same person so I am leaving my review under Dr. Smith since it is at the same address. I have been to so many different OB/GYN's in Boardman and wait literally hours for every single appointment. Dr. Eucker has seen me on time every single visit, and I really appreciate that. He's also very thorough and takes his time with you. He says he runs on time because he doesn't deliver babies, but I don't need an OB just a GYN. So, if you just need GYN yearly check ups, this is a great office with no waiting.

I was treated rudely by staff as well as they incorrectly billed my charges and I was stuck with bill. They also would not listen when I told them I had a mammogram less than 12 m ago and ended up stuck with that bill also. Then when I called to have them re submit bill with correct codes they refused. When I tried to stress that it’s costing me for their error they did not care. They were rude , even hung up on me. I then got a letter from their office no longer going to see me as a patient. Worse experience I ever had. Doctor would not listen to my concerns, very dismissive.

She is by far the best obgyn I've been to. I had several problems with cysts and she did excellent surgery to remove them and all follow up was professional and gentle. She is by far the best obgyn I've expierence in this area. I have been going to her ever since (around 7 years).

I was appalled by Dr. Smith's unprofessional nature. It's pretty clear she wants her patients to have a perfect sexual history, with one partner in their entire lives. She is also very pro birth control and when I let her know I wasn't interested based on how it affects hormone levels, she rudely informed me that an unplanned pregnancy would have a way bigger impact on my hormones than birth control. Excuse me? She doesn't care about your opinion at all, which is funny, because it's your body.