I honestly woulda given 3 stars, but three stars is listed as "good", and I would grade her as "mediocre". She gave basically 1 useful piece of advice each time, but she wasn't all that interested in me and my condition, so she failed to a) give me the sense that reaching conclusions based on all evidence available and b) verify I understood how to implement her advice. All in all, visiting with her reminds me of those textbooks that discuss the problem of patients not fully disclosing relevant information to doctors because the patient is ashamed or the doctor is uninterested.